orrrrrrrrrrr you can congratulate the people who made it (since everyone worked hard) and improve your gfx to be accepted next year!..

orrrrrrrrrrr not

Then you should probably do a massive edit where it isnt even visible that the graphic was edited.

There were over 200 submissions. The best and most liked ones were the ones that were chosen. Some of you only got a couple things you made accepted out of all because the ones that were picked were liked more than the ones that weren't.

I find that hysterical because you expect people to congratulate you but you then deem as below you even though only a handfull of the picked actually had been practising gfx for more than a year.Looking at a slight fraction of the submissions I can tell that this was not soley down to quality at least I hope otherwise classic staff have made some terrible mistakes. Your not in a position to pass judgement over everyone.


I hope everyone does not get discouraged by being denied and continues to make graphics.

Congrats to those who had items accepted. People will have their opinions on what was chosen, however they can't change what happened :0. So have a Merry Christmas and stop whining! :D

But they know all
they can see whats an edit and whats not even if it was a random hat nobody wears edited

I hope people are aware that even for graphics staff, not all graphics we create make the "cut" for various reasons.

Ya I was just thinking that lol. You should see how much gets denied!

Seconded.. err.. third..ed o.o :D

as someone who had to make three hat lists for tower guilds this year, I'd be surprised with the staff if they were even able to accept 10% of what was submitted

not sure why people are up in the air and not understanding why their submissions didn't earn them a free hat

some of my items were accepted, but i didn't receive them, and i know they were accepted because i saw other players wearing them, and in the submission i asked to get all of which is accepted:c..
i only got 2 of the ones i made that were accepted ; u ;

Send me a forum PM of the hats you didn't get and I'll add it. Sorry about that.

Question, near the beginning of the year some hats were sold in nafets that was given as a christmas gift so does that mean more hats are to do the same?

How rare are the player made items?