what if im non american and the amendment's don't apply to me :[

i think it'll still apply because it's an American game. idk or france rule applys to the game.

How is it an American game? The company that owns the game is based in France.

Then France rule applies or the internet rules.

In canada the french have a whole province of their own to avoid that. And there are still a great many of us candians who have terrible french and take pride in it...

Lol amendmants don't apply in game. The same way you aren't protected if you yell **** in a preschool.

Amendments in graal??? Seriously?? this is too funny. Jokes aside lets get this suggestion implemented it will really be beneficial to guilds. In many MMOs this option is already available, would be logical to have this in graal as well. If there are abuses by the guildleaders, its really an internal thing and you can always quit the guild if you dont like the rules. These are private guilds, not the friggin civil service.

Yeah, u kidding? some japanese games were banned from US cause they weren't suitable with US laws.
If Toonslab is selling gralat packs in US, they are following the US law. Maybe not amendments, but laws for games.

I have towered for a long time and have never once been in a situation where this is needed. If someone is talking enough to the point where they sould get guild chat taken away, they probably aren't helping much anyways and should be kicked.

This will make Graal anti-social. Its not needed.

I see no issues. Those who don't like it can leave said guild and form their own guild called "Happy Spam Guild" and live the lives they always wanted. Plenty of guilds to join out there, if you join one that doesn't let you chat, either endure that restriction, or leave. Simplicity in it's finest.

You are right about laws. Since we are talking about laws lets cite precedence hehe. In this particular case, WoW is based in america and WoW has that function.
http://guildrelationswow.wikia.com/w...d_Ranks:_a_FAQ

"Some guilds like to have a punishment/probation rank where certain member privileges are revoked as a warning to guildies who act up. For example, some GLs have a "mute" rank where people who abuse the guild chat are placed until they either /gquit or learn the error of their ways. "

This muting thing isnt new its been around since there were MMOs. im sure many other games based in america has that as well

Im not saying that we should follow WOW in everything but that "amendments" and even "law" just isnt part of the reason why we shouldnt have the mute button.

WoW that's interesting. It's kinda messed up. If they are annoying, u have block button or kick them though. Doesn't really need to mute somebody. Game law should protect it.

Wtf is this game law crap you won't stop babbling about?

http://www.graalonline.com/docs/conduct
or should i say 'code of conduct'? sounds better?