You may not agree with some of my ideas but if this is how guilds worked i think graal would be better and more competitive.
1. Loyalty
2. New guild events
3. Restrictions on making guilds
4. Seasonal tournies and seasonal reseting
5. player limit.
Loyalty
I am in 10 guilds. One, i am actually loyal to, ruthless. I think everybody should have to choose one guild to be in, and once you join a guild you can not join another guild untill you leave your orginal guild. So now tower guilds and spar guilds would actually have compition.
I cannot name every person in (Obsidian) or any tower guilf because there are too many temps, with this update it would be harder to find temps and guilds would actually need skilled loyal active players for towers.
New guild events
-Guild spar
-Towers
-CTF
-king of the hill
-tag team spar
-pk total
-spar total
CTF would be a 4vs4 guild vs guild ctf match winner gets a better rating.
King of the hill would be a new areana where guilds meet to play a 6vs6 king of the hill, whoever owns the hill for the most time after 2 minutes wins and their king of the hill rating will go up.
tag team spar- read my tag team spar forum
pk total- total number of pks each guild member has gotten while on the guild tag
spar total- same thing with 1vs1 spars
seasonal reseting and rating
The guild members with the best ratings in the leaderboards will gain 10,000 gralats per month if they are #1. 5,000 if #2 and 2,000 for #3
and the ratings per catagory will be reset seasonally, even the tower times.
Making guilds
in order to make a guild you need 10 people to agree to be in it.
So when you click make guild it will pop up as, add 10 friends and 10 friends will get a message would you like to pay 500 gralats to help make (Ruthless) you have been chosen by Qes to be a founder of Ruthless. the guild wont be added untill 10 people accept to being loyal.
Player limit
if this stops noob recruiting and sub guilds than the max of players should become 30
also i forgot to add that GST will excist, CTFT capture the flag tourny will excist seasonally and so would Tag team spar 2vs2 monthly
added-
well if you were only allowed to be in one guild that would mean you lead a guild or join a guild. and if it is harder to make a guild (10 people required who pay 500 to show their loyalty) than there would be more people joining guilds than making one. So tower guilds would be run by popular pkers who would recruit the most active pkers. than some guilds can be created by people who dont spar or do towers and they would recruit people who dont spar or do towers. than a well known or a good leader that spars can make a guild and recruit his good friends that also spar.
So compition for spar guids would be more legit
Loyalty would be real for tower guilds too.
And for all of you gfx, admins or social people you can make a guild full of your friends and they cant leave tag unlesd they leave your guild so you'd actually bond and get to know your members. Temp guild spar tags wouldnt excist so guilds cant 2vs5 unless they are fine with ruining score. boosting in guild spar would decrease. Noob recruiting tower guilds would decrease.
Allies would be allies.
Tower guilds can use the ally option so that the most active pkers get a main tag, and than after that the less active guild members would join an allied guild, like Obsidian II.
But they would stay loyal to obsidian because it would no longer be a race to 1k hours to get a hat it would be a race to #1 on the seasonal leaderboards so you can get a hat or custom gfx of anything every season if you get 1st 2nd or 3rd in seasonal leaderboards.
OR MY 2ND IDEA
You can not multi guild you are allowed one guild.
But if you are in a guild with allies you can be in both the guild you were orginally in and all of the allied guilds.
This would allow towered to recruit temporary helpers but only if they are in an allied branch, this was used by Zanza when they had helsing as a tower guild.
I came up with this idea for Ventrue and Any tower guild.
It would still prevent multiguilding but allow allies to wear eachothers tags.
So Racil can be in Cotorie Ventrue and VV and have powers in all 3.
So azreal can still have powers in all Zanza branches
So Obsidian and other tower guilds can still recruit members from 'sub guilds' but you cant join any other guilds except for your guild and the allied guilds.
Unally
when you Unally a guild it would say "Would you like to leave Obsidian or Obsidian II to all the members who were orginally in both guilds