i dont see any flaws in my guild update. but i see why pkers and Socializing people would dislike this so i will add a graal guild ideas 4.0 soon with ideas from me rufus and everybody elses input ive goten so far and ill keep editing it untill i find a fun new guild system that works for everybody.

For those of you who are fine with the orginal system it is probably becase you dont realize how boring graal gets after being in a guild full of noobs you dont even know. Im being honest i had the most fun in this game when i was a noob, because i enjoyed simple things in graal like pking and messaging now 3 years later all i do is pm spar and guild spar, so i would like to add more things to create compition.
I enjoy being in a loyalty guild because ive gotten to know my members like roxas guizmo voodoo pikahika ect ect so well... I know their spar styles where the live how old they are, they're personality ... all of these things you can gain without loyalty but together its like we are one big team win or lose.
So i understand now this forcing loyalty is a long shot because its not 'fair' to those who dont understand loyalty yet.
So my opinion mixe with the commentary i got will be coming soon in Guild ideas 4.0... for now please comment your ideas so i can steal them and give you credit