Off the top of my head
Candy
Egg Nog
2010(?) 4th of July bandana
Rainbow Pet
Rainbow Pogo
Rainbow Octopus
First honor point hat, Nurse
Nutcracker
Light Up Jumprope
Fairy
Goblin
Holiday Box
Wind Pet
Swamp Pet (not that rare)
Water Pet
Rock Pet
I would have to go onto my account to find the rest. Also, I have a ton of old hats.