Yeah, that's what I thought. I should probably just stop going for them. I hate Pokegen. It ruins trades for other people if you trade them a phony Pokemon and it's not fair when you use them in online battles when you didn't earn those stats legitly. Turns out the guy was a con-artist though. I deleted the HM and tried trading back, but he immediately offered a Mighteyana titled "Shiny Weavile". I was hoping he just wrote his description incorrectly by mistake and he'd give it back, but I was sadly mistaken.