Heres the thing, if this system IS implemented then there is no incentive to pk or defend. Player killing stat would be removed from players profiles because nobody would care about them. So far i've only seen maybe two or three alumni members in favor of this idea, which is a little weird. I don't see any motivation to tower if a guild of VPN users (not saying alumni) were to multi tower when all their doing is making the "raiding" guild's odds unfavorable.