Thanks everyone for voting, but due to some errors I did with this thread I wasn't able to get accurate results for what I was looking for.
Errors:
Project A was the original piece
Project B was an edited version done by a different person (
problem was that it was a rushed job that was not polished-which he mentions, but I didn't catch it)
Even with a rushed Project B I could have adjusted by adding a 4th option to the poll to dislike both projects(having no choice but to pick from possibly 2 bad pieces doesn't give me an accurate answer to what I was looking for)
|
If it was an example of how pillow shading can look better than using proper lighting than it is a BS example for obvious reasons.
|
Yes Psymon, I'm on a mission to convince the art community that pillow shading is greater than all other shading styles.
I just wanted to see if regular players would like a pillow shaded piece. Artists already have it in their head that pillow shading is bad, so anything they see with pillow shading is automatically ugly and that's why I asked them not to critic it (didn't want them to influence the voting)
Link to the thread where I got the pictures:
http://wayofthepixel.net/index.php?topic=15999.0
I like things from both works, so don't think it was a shading vs shading thing.