Yes Psymon, I'm on a mission to convince the art community that pillow shading is greater than all other shading styles. 
I just wanted to see if regular players would like a pillow shaded piece. Artists already have it in their head that pillow shading is bad, so anything they see with pillow shading is automatically ugly and that's why I asked them not to critic it (didn't want them to influence the voting)
Link to the thread where I got the pictures:
http://wayofthepixel.net/index.php?topic=15999.0
I like things from both works, so don't think it was a shading vs shading thing. |
I think every reasonable artist would agree the first is better whether or not its pillowshaded. Its not that something can't look good pillowshaded, its that it would look better if it wasn't.