It's not just black and white. Some people like it, some dont, and some are between those two. Im inbetween the two, probably since I started in 2010 and I was used to how classic was back then. So while I do think the outdoor tiles on the tileset could use a little more detail since the overworld (imo) looks kinda plain, I don't dismiss the new style as bad. I do like a good share of the hats that come out, the horses (mounts....), etc.