This doesn't take into account that a guild might do for an example soar and tower , it limits a guild to specific game style ,furthermore I'm pretty sure the new system will merge pk spar and tower into one reward pot so having these is bassically pointless ( if this is true ) .

Furthermore more let's say this was gonna happen for a reason or another , how would you even define the popularity of a social guild ? There is no point value that makes any social guild better than another