Strongly disagree. Attack on Titan was hype as hell. I personally can't remember seeing anything with such compelling and unexpected twists and turns. Every time I thought I knew how things were headed, it got flip-turned upside down. I only heard about it like two months ago, and I watched every episode of season 1 multiple times in both dub and sub, and read through the manga. I haven't watched any anime since the original non Shippuden Naruto, but Attack on Titan was too good not to see the whole product. It even got me back to trying different manga, I've only been keeping up with One Piece chapters. Now I just finished Claymore and started on The Seven Deadly Sins, with multiple other interesting manga on backlog. How such great storytelling and artwork can be called mediocre makes me a bit sad.