You could enter without having 50 members, just being awarded points would be useless.
They would of looked at this from every angle and found something that made sense and worked well.
|
Gst shouldn't be linked with the NGS, they shouldn't make "guild points" as a reward for gst. Otherwise, half of those "50" players gonna be gsing in belle/ba which will effect the daily points of the guild. Also, it's going to be awkward when you only pick 7 members even tho some others practiced in ba/belle too..
|
Wow it's almost like you can't just plan your recruitment process to recruit different people who are interested in different activities to avoid issues like these
|
Why the GST should be left untouched when the NGS is implemented:
-Would be lopsided and the same guild would take home the 1st place points every season...
|
Lol, don't act like this isn't already the case
|
-Not every guild member is deserving of the 1st place points in a guild that wins.
|
You clearly don't understand the point of the system, everyone makes individual contributions and people who do so through spar are just doing theirs.
|
-No g-sparrer that isn't already top 10-20 has improved in 2 years, so recruiting would be necessary- you then get punished for that?
|
What do you mean 'necessary'? Just have people practice more and get better, where's your logic here?
|
-GS activeness would drop from GST month to GST week. No reward=no motivation.
|
Again lol, this 'activity' is people sparring, getting high points(or boosting) and stopping, then sparring only in places like Delta Island, nothing is going to change.
|
-5/25 (5/50?) members can actually spar? lol fun
|
Plan your recruitment process? Not all 50 people are going to want to spar, the point is to gather people who are interested in different activities of the game.
|
-The GST right now would still be more fun than the NGS (in the long term.) No need for change
|
Can't say this until you've tried it.