Guilds aren't meant to be limited-time vessels for holiday get-togethers. If you want a guild specifically for doing holiday events together, then name your guild accordingly. Then get a group of people who are willing to be together for every event.



So for the new guild recruitment-by-request applications -- when denying a request, i think the "are you sure" confirmation is unnecessary, and the "you have rejected such-and-such request" message is also unnecessary. It should be a one-click reject and one-click accept; and if accepted, the "successfully recruited to guild" message is okay.