1k guild without subs/noobcruiting? - 2

Thallen · 03-06-2013

Once I hit 10000-999 spars, I'm starting to tower. I'd be more motivated to put together a guild like this if there was some extra reward for doing it. Otherwise, it's just applying more effort for the same prize. Not sure if worth it.

PennyShine · 03-06-2013

Posted by GotenGraal

PiNoY had 1 sub only for a while and did pretty good. And yeah it's possible, look at Mau5trap, no subs, no allies, and 300 hours of fort time. Once in a while you may see a new face but really it was the same people you'd see at swamp taking down VG. But with the same 25 anyone could probably do it, it'd just take an extremely long amount of time lol. And noob recruiting I consider is recruiting random noobs who walk inside the tower your at. If a newer player asks if they can help I don't see the point in saying no, I like to give everyone a chance, I don't consider it noob recruiting if the "noob" asks to help.

Yeah I agree, what I meant to say was noobcruiting is recruiting random people that don't even ask for a tag

G Fatal · 03-06-2013

Posted by Xavier

I always toyed with the idea of doing a 1k guild completely by myself while the Facebook server existed. Thought it would have been a good laugh.

Lol I did this aswell sometimes getting hrs alone then thought it was boring as hell so stopped.

Pazx · 03-16-2013

Posted by GotenGraal

PiNoY had 1 sub only for a while and did pretty good. And yeah it's possible, look at Mau5trap, no subs, no allies, and 300 hours of fort time. Once in a while you may see a new face but really it was the same people you'd see at swamp taking down VG. But with the same 25 anyone could probably do it, it'd just take an extremely long amount of time lol. And noob recruiting I consider is recruiting random noobs who walk inside the tower your at. If a newer player asks if they can help I don't see the point in saying no, I like to give everyone a chance, I don't consider it noob recruiting if the "noob" asks to help.

Mau5 noobcruited.

Posted by GotenGraal

Here's a former noob recruit of PiNoY^^^

10/10

Thallen · 03-22-2013

Subs and nubs don't strike me as a problem. What I see as more of an issue is the fact that certain tower guilds share between the same members. It doesn't really make sense to me, there are a handful of players who seem to freely jump between multiple competing guilds and never really stick to one. Names that come to mind are people like Mya, Ivan, Nadine, the Bob guy or whatever his name is, and others. Clearly it's their choice to do what they want, but why would you want to do that rather than remain loyal and dedicated to one guild?

That's more of a sign of careless or poor leadership, IMO. Just weird for me to see a player badmouth one guild on one day and join it and defend a tower with them the next day. And then, the next day they're in the next guild, attacking the first guild's tower. Then the cycle repeats. I don't really understand it or why leaders let it happen.

It's why I sort of respect guilds like NAL and SoN above others. Their members seem to be committed to one guild, and that's cool.

GotenGraal · 03-22-2013

Bob is Rebellious all the way lol, he helps Vintage occasionally only when you're there Thallen. Ivan is just always switching around and Mya is like Bob except she's mainly Vintage but likes to help us when Thallen is attacking lol. And Nadine was your member so I don't know about her, but she seems to like to help any guild you're attacking.

Thallen · 03-22-2013

Posted by GotenGraal

he helps Vintage occasionally only when you're there Thallen

No idea why, I don't even know him.

Posted by GotenGraal

Mya is like Bob except she's mainly Vintage but likes to help us when Thallen is attacking

Do you guys have an anti-Thallen task force?

Posted by GotenGraal

And Nadine was your member so I don't know about her, but she seems to like to help any guild you're attacking.

She was kicked for doing exactly what I'm talking about, jumping around guilds.

Either way, it's exactly what I'm talking about. I'd rather see a guild recruit randoms and stack in their subs rather than see the entire competitive towering community recycle the same members. What do Bob, Mya, or Nadine do when Rebellious and Vintage are attacking each other? Have a panic attack? Cally is in that group also, probably several others.

GotenGraal · 03-22-2013

Nope lol Bob helps us and Mya and Nadine help Vintage. We have done long attacks on Vintage at Sardon many times before, I don't care if it fails for hours, in the end we usually get the enemy to rage badly and they get cocky forgetting sardon is extremely easy to hold lol. I don't know about the anti-Thallen force, I don't ask anyone to help Vintage when SF is there nor do I ask Vintage to help me out. But basically the long sardon attacks is nothing personal, we have done this to nearly every guild that holds sardon a decent amount.

Eldon · 03-22-2013

The lesson word today is: Loyalty! ^_^

Thallen · 03-22-2013

It's your choice to assemble and recruit an elite squadron of anti-Thallen soldiers, I don't really mind. I just think guildwhoring is less respectable than the two points mentioned in this thread and wanted to mention it, that's all.

If anyone actually rewards temporary fill-ins like this with a hat at their 1K mark (which seems to be what they want sometimes) then know that you're completely disrespecting the loyal members of your guild. Use them, don't let them use you.

GotenGraal · 03-22-2013

If someone wants to help us i'm not going to deny them even if there only reason is because they have something against SF. But really most of my members are completely loyal to Rebellious now, cameback to get almost another 1k with no hat on the line this time, to me I think this shows loyalty. There isn't that many members who help me just to mess with you guys. Bob has been with us before you guys came on the map,
so basically it's just Cally, Nadine, and Mya but they help Vintage way more than us lol.

twilit · 03-23-2013

Hey guise! i has a brilliant idea! why dont we dig up every old thread, and then go completely off topic to bich about competing guilds and we can start flame warzzz!!!!1!!!11

Seriously, if you hate eachother, there's this handy-dandy feature called private messages you guys should use instead of making it public where no one else cares.

GotenGraal · 03-23-2013

Posted by twilit

Hey guise! i has a brilliant idea! why dont we dig up every old thread, and then go completely off topic to bich about competing guilds and we can start flame warzzz!!!!1!!!11

Seriously, if you hate eachother, there's this handy-dandy feature called private messages you guys should use instead of making it public where no one else cares.

Hey mykul there's also a unsubscribe button you should use it! And I didn't realize this was a flame war... Seems like were just arguing our opinions calmly, where is the flaming?

03-06-2013	16
Thallen Enguard & Alumni Join Date: Sep 2011 Posts: 5,773	Once I hit 10000-999 spars, I'm starting to tower. I'd be more motivated to put together a guild like this if there was some extra reward for doing it. Otherwise, it's just applying more effort for the same prize. Not sure if worth it.

03-22-2013	20
Thallen Enguard & Alumni Join Date: Sep 2011 Posts: 5,773	Subs and nubs don't strike me as a problem. What I see as more of an issue is the fact that certain tower guilds share between the same members. It doesn't really make sense to me, there are a handful of players who seem to freely jump between multiple competing guilds and never really stick to one. Names that come to mind are people like Mya, Ivan, Nadine, the Bob guy or whatever his name is, and others. Clearly it's their choice to do what they want, but why would you want to do that rather than remain loyal and dedicated to one guild? That's more of a sign of careless or poor leadership, IMO. Just weird for me to see a player badmouth one guild on one day and join it and defend a tower with them the next day. And then, the next day they're in the next guild, attacking the first guild's tower. Then the cycle repeats. I don't really understand it or why leaders let it happen. It's why I sort of respect guilds like NAL and SoN above others. Their members seem to be committed to one guild, and that's cool.

03-22-2013	21
GotenGraal helo utub Join Date: Feb 2012 Posts: 1,225	Bob is Rebellious all the way lol, he helps Vintage occasionally only when you're there Thallen. Ivan is just always switching around and Mya is like Bob except she's mainly Vintage but likes to help us when Thallen is attacking lol. And Nadine was your member so I don't know about her, but she seems to like to help any guild you're attacking.

03-22-2013	24
Eldon Registered User Join Date: Feb 2013 Location: Battle Arena Bench Posts: 277	The lesson word today is: Loyalty! ^_^

03-23-2013	27
twilit michael Join Date: May 2012 Location: Hyrule Posts: 3,511	Hey guise! i has a brilliant idea! why dont we dig up every old thread, and then go completely off topic to bich about competing guilds and we can start flame warzzz!!!!1!!!11 Seriously, if you hate eachother, there's this handy-dandy feature called private messages you guys should use instead of making it public where no one else cares.