Posted by iChronic

yaa.. can you also do this for all towers not just castle? Kinda annoyed when guilds make this a part of towering.. i think one of the worst cases is in sards where people can just run through spikes

anyway it would be nice if you make that happen..i also had a similar idea..everytime your death is self inflicted then your kills gets deducted by 1..i think that seems fair right?

I agree that there should be something that deters players from killing themselves but I don't think that it should damage stats.



Feedback for the review: At the end of your review for castle you say this: "It felt to me like with one or two more skilled people we might be able to break through and take it, and that’s a feeling I never got at Deadwood."

The way you said it made it sound like a bad thing. I don't think you should be able to take a tower with only 2 people. (except for maybe York because that's just a fort for noob guilds) I think that taking a tower should be a team effort, not just a few people.

Other than that though it was pretty interesting to read this and hear some opinions. I also thought that the timing of how long it takes to get back into a tower was pretty interesting.  

Posted by Meteor

I agree that there should be something that deters players from killing themselves but I don't think that it should damage stats.



Feedback for the review: At the end of your review for castle you say this: "It felt to me like with one or two more skilled people we might be able to break through and take it, and that’s a feeling I never got at Deadwood."

The way you said it made it sound like a bad thing. I don't think you should be able to take a tower with only 2 people. (except for maybe York because that's just a fort for noob guilds) I think that taking a tower should be a team effort, not just a few people.

Other than that though it was pretty interesting to read this and hear some opinions. I also thought that the timing of how long it takes to get back into a tower was pretty interesting.

I hear ya, but put the emphasis there on the "skilled." I was saying that I liked the fact that being good at pking actually matters in the castle. Even though defenders have a major advantage with respawn distance, a few skilled players might be able to take the castle from a greater number of unskilled players.

At somewhere like Sardons, as long as the defenders aren't idle, there is really very little chance you can take those towers without having more people than the defending guild has, no matter how good you are.  

I think that Sardon's Tower is the poorest excuse for a guild fort that we have. This can be attributed to the fact that it was never intended to be a guild fort area. Sardon's Tower has always housed a quest, and the levels that are used in the tower are from this quest. I don't think it could be edited in a way that would make it a suitable guild fort either without really changing its structure entirely. If we were going to do that it may as well be reverted back to its original quest form and a tower could go elsewhere. That's just my personal opinion though, it will probably stay as it is.  

Posted by Rufus

I think that Sardon's Tower is the poorest excuse for a guild fort that we have. This can be attributed to the fact that it was never intended to be a guild fort area. Sardon's Tower has always housed a quest, and the levels that are used in the tower are from this quest. I don't think it could be edited in a way that would make it a suitable guild fort either without really changing its structure entirely. If we were going to do that it may as well be reverted back to its original quest form and a tower could go elsewhere. That's just my personal opinion though, it will probably stay as it is.

Balamb fort 2013  

^yes  

Remove all towers except castle, profit. 200+ people fighting over the most balanced tower.  

Posted by HON3Y BADG3R

In our defense, it is nearly impossible to squeeze 16 players all going at the same time into the flag room since 4-6 can only hit. You also got those bomb/arrow spammers. Plus we are not all towers (US is made up of the elite)

Idea: NO BOMBS/ARROWS IN TOWER

That is pathetic excuse to cover up the lame towering your guild did. Here's an idea, get 4-6 people to attack the flag WHILE the rest of the guild covers the stairs to stop Vintage (the guild that was holding Deadwood at the time) from going to the flag room. Who's idea was it to squeeze 16 players into the flag room? Lol, ******ed much? It's how you plan things out, not the amount of players you have on your attack force. I witenessed 15+ players on Graalian tag or sub tag camping inside Deadwood hat shop and after 5mins of attack, your guild died out. Pretty much, stay on the forum because it's pointless making a guild for Graalians if ya suck at everything.  

Posted by twilit

I dont think this is poor design rather than "the element of surprise." Attacking with 16 people, the defenders become wide awake and active and actually try. When only 2 persistant people are attacking, the defenders tire out and think "meh, someone else'll get 'em" and everyone afks and its an easy take. I see this in other towers too. Some days ill get Castle flag in the double digits before SoN wakes up.

I agree with this 100%  

Posted by Vladdy

US took over Deadwood quicker than Graalians did, compare their 15+ members online to our 4 members.

Oh man you are so 1337 pr0 at towering, I bet you're the coolest guy at your school.

Posted by Rezon

Remove all towers except castle, profit. 200+ people fighting over the most balanced tower.

that would be awesome ahaha  

At deadwood you could double the size of the stairs  

Posted by Santa Claus

I agree with this 100%

You agree because you experienced the same with Tom xD  

Posted by twilit

You agree because you experienced the same with Tom xD

soooooo...
I do it from time to time as well when I pk.