A guild log history that every guild member can see that says anything anyone does in the guild like:

Who kicks who
Who recruits who
Who changes whose rank
Who edits the guild news

Although its easier said than done and I respect that you guys are busy with other things, but I would personally love to see this in the future.

It would solve the mystery of who did what and i think im not alone on this suggestion.  

! Yes  

Im glad you agree!  

Make it happen. I guess.  

Cool idea. i rlly like it.  

I don't think guild activities should be posted for the general public or all guild members for that matter. It would be fine for the guild leader to be able to look at it or possibly enable co-leads to look at it.

Like I posted in another thread if you give ppl the ability to see who kicked them its just going to create more un-needed drama within the guild system.  

I think it's ironic how you think differently..you do realize that the main purpose of Strap's idea is to deter unneeded drama? I always hear of people getting kicked out of a guild or getting assigned with a rude rank and because there isn't a log that tracks changes in the guild, the culprit's identity remains preserved and as a result no one gets the blame.

With a working guild log these problems would become obsolete. The culprit who changes ranks, kicks people or writes rude messages in GN could easily be identified.  

This idea has been suggested maybe five times? I think it's kind of usefull in some cases, but it's useless aswell.

I doubt it'll be added any soon.  

Couple of those suggestions were me xD. I'd like this to be added but I also I think they won't add it.  

Posted by iChronic

I think it's ironic how you think differently..you do realize that the main purpose of Strap's idea is to deter unneeded drama? I always hear of people getting kicked out of a guild or getting assigned with a rude rank and because there isn't a log that tracks changes in the guild, the culprit's identity remains preserved and as a result no one gets the blame.

With a working guild log these problems would become obsolete. The culprit who changes ranks, kicks people or writes rude messages in GN could easily be identified.

1.Most of the ppl that get kicked or atleast that I have kicked have deserved it for being rude,disrespecting other members of the guild,afking to much,or disobeying orders from a lead.

It's been my experience that when you kick a person they don't seem to understand why or wont acknowledge what they did. Most cases ppl are kicked for space and don't get how towering guilds work and get butt hurt ignoring the fact they are not perms and are subject to being removed from the guild for space. This is why every single guild uses sub tags for ppl to get their tags back when they come back on line and yet even pro-ish ppl don't seem to get it.

2.I did say that it should only be view able by the guild's leader or co-leader if the leader so desires. If any member of the guild can see the logs it will create more drama not curb it. I do agree it would be nice if they added more tools for leads to use in managing their guilds.  

Posted by ufoburan

1.Most of the ppl that get kicked or atleast that I have kicked have deserved it for being rude,disrespecting other members of the guild,afking to much,or disobeying orders from a lead.


2. If any member of the guild can see the logs it will create more drama not curb it.

ya, i meant perms getting kicked..I still can't see how this would create drama though.  

Posted by iChronic

ya, i meant perms getting kicked..I still can't see how this would create drama though.

Ppl are always wanting perm spots it all but guarantees them a hat spot. So of course if they get kicked they are gonna rage no matter the reason why they got kicked. If they can get back on tag and see who kicked them then they will more than likely start bickering and arguing with that person and raging at them. Which would be unnecessary drama and a distraction to the guild. If they cant see who did it then they cant do that. Trust me I have seen this happen as it is.

I'm not saying guild logs are a bad idea at all In fact I think its a great idea but should just be limited to the guild leader or given as a permission by the leader(they can click a little box allowing that person to view the logs).

Also if its only the leader or co leader then they will be able to look at the log if some dummy decides to get smart and kick the entire guild so they know not to recruit him back.  

Posted by ufoburan

I don't think guild activities should be posted for the general public or all guild members for that matter. It would be fine for the guild leader to be able to look at it or possibly enable co-leads to look at it.

Like I posted in another thread if you give ppl the ability to see who kicked them its just going to create more un-needed drama within the guild system.

I agree with Buran  

Or set a option to let them see the guild logs.. lol  

Also adding "Who left the guild" would be nice.