I was having a kicking problem with a guild a while back and I was thinking, wouldnt it be good if they added a guild log for things like who get kicked by who, who recruit who and who got certain powers. It is kinda pointless but who cares  

Yea... i think there should be a feature like this... but only the leader could access that log.or maybe the leader could give a new power to certain peeps called "Can access Guild Log".
Good Idea. (At the same time..a little pointless too.)  

Why would you suggest something in the first place when 'it is kinda pointless' ..?

However, it might be useful because you can track the activity of your guild members, and see if anyone is not abusing their kick powers etc and are doing as they are told - so it's no where near pointless.  

Posted by Xenice

Why would you suggest something in the first place when 'it is kinda pointless' ..?

Because the idea is not bad...its just pointless.we dnt need anything like that in Graal.?but its a Good idea xD
its just something which is Good but Pointless for Graal.  

Posted by MBK

Because the idea is not bad...its just pointless.we dnt need anything like that in Graal.?but its a Good idea xD
its just something which is Good but Pointless for Graal.

But that's not the whole point of suggesting something.If it's pointless, why suggest it? Even if it ain't bad - it's still pointless - meaning it's useless, and wouldn't have a good impact on the server.

This section are for things you'd like to see added in Graal. If it's pointless in Graal, then why post in the improvements section?

Also, this idea isn't that pointless in my opinion.  

Posted by Xenice

But that's not the whole point of suggesting something.If it's pointless, why suggest it? Even if it ain't bad - it's still pointless - meaning it's useless, and wouldn't have a good impact on the server.

This section are for things you'd like to see added in Graal. If it's pointless in Graal, then why suggest it?

Well Pointless doent always mean that its bad for the server.York Town is quite Pointless and is Outdated compared to the other towns...but it doesnt hurt us or the server in the slightest.  

Posted by MBK

Well Pointless doent always mean that its bad for the server.York Town is quite Pointless and is Outdated compared to the other towns...but it doesnt hurt us or the server in the slightest.

York Town and suggesting pointless things in the improvements section are two different subjects. Some may argue York Town is not pointless, it provides a role-playing environment - events can be hosted there such as horse racing - it adds more to the server.

However, back on to suggesting 'pointless' suggestions. Pointless - useless; useless good or bad? Bad. Do we want useless suggestions? No - because why? We want useful suggestions.  

Lol im starting to understand why People stopped me for Posting on Graalians.
ok no Guild Logs...its pointless and good but no guild logs.i hope this satisfies you. /('.')/
btw i didnt suggested it.i just made an OPINION.  

If I had a dollar for everytime i heard this suggestion......

Should be added  

Posted by MBK

Lol im starting to understand why People stopped me for Posting on Graalians.
ok no Guild Logs...its pointless and good but no guild logs.i hope this satisfies you. /('.')/
btw i didnt suggested it.i just made an OPINION.

I'm glad you understand now.

My opinion - Not pointless - therefore good. If something is pointless- it's meaningless and useless. This suggestion is not meaningless or useless, therefore it's not pointless. I like this idea, should be added because it's not pointless. The word 'pointless' is not the right word to describe this suggestion. That is where i'm coming from.


Your opinion - it's pointless but good.
Your opinion after my post - pointless and good but no guild logs

Makes no sense but yes, it satisfies me.

I didn't say you suggested it. Thanks for your OPINION.  

Btw u couldve just said "MBK ur wrong.We need Guild Logs."  

Good idea. I think maybe it could also be useful for determining how many tower hours certain players had logged in the guild?

That might get tricky, though...  

Storing logs of each and every guild of Classic.it may be a major update if it was Ever implemented...which i doubt.  

Posted by MBK

Btw u couldve just said "MBK ur wrong.We need Guild Logs."

I wasn't talking about whether you were wrong or not. I was talking about suggesting something which is pointless - and also that this suggestion was not pointless. Oh my.  

What I would love for guilds would be a flag with your guild logo on it so you can put it in a guild house or whatever