Posted by David M.

Show real support by giving me feedback instead of this dumb rage thread which won't help anyone.

I see a lot of pillowshading which is the main thing you need to work on
A little bit of room for improvement on the lineart as well

Also some of the ideas aren't that exciting, taking a random object (e.g. a camera) and putting it on a players hat doesn't make that great of a hat imo  

Posted by David M.

Show real support by giving me feedback instead of this dumb rage thread which won't help anyone.

Pillowshading is a nono.
Line art is kinda eh, it could be better on ones like the bowling pin.  

Posted by shinoclassic

I totally agree with you Ivy. I saw the hats you submitted on instagram, they were adorable. Graal has to expand its horizons on Christmas hats. The ones I got last year were ****ty. What a shame. :/

Same happened to me lol, but I got like 1 hat last year. Worthless garbage.  

Posted by ChocoNotes

Dollys witch and ear hats definitely should have
An almost identical butterfly hat is already on graal and the rest really lack shading so look a bit eh

But yeah, thread is useless

yea, i really wanted my ears ; n ; and the butterfly wings aren't like the wings on graal, it's like the angel winglet hats that are on top of the head, but i agree, i try to keep it simple but it ends up plain looking most of the times, woops  

make the community vote placelol  

Also Ivy, this is a neutral post so don't flame at me for it. Had you only posted about your hats and not dolly's or storm's then you'd look like a fool without a shield to back you up. Chances are your hats weren't accepted for a damn good reason, not because you were treated unfairly. Honestly, Leah isn't gonna go out of her way to do that, she chose the hats she felt met her standards(I think???). I also honestly don't know why you singled me out, I'm new and wouldn't care if my hats got in but I was happy when they got in, but you ended up bashing on me because yours didn't.  

None of my hats were added to my account. Does this mean they weren't accepted?
A lot of my hats were 10x better than some of the **** that got accepted this year  

Posted by Albie

None of my hats were added to my account. Does this mean they weren't accepted?
A lot of my hats were 10x better than some of the **** that got accepted this year

Weren't some of the ones you posted copyright iirc?  

Posted by Striken

Weren't some of the ones you posted copyright iirc?

Nah, I changed em





The only thing that could maybe infringe copyright would be the black swirly mask, yet there's a blue version in game. Copyright wouldn't be able to touch the others. E.G I think my hat is pretty good, the letter z isn't copyrighted.

And then these hats


Got denied even though they're better than some current hats being sold imo

My submission email:

Tough:
http://i.imgur.com/E4Tkpdk.png
http://i.imgur.com/qtW75pR.png
http://i.imgur.com/hQVoosM.png

Cute:
http://i.imgur.com/c2qM2XK.png
http://i.imgur.com/dXRMKpy.png

Cool:
http://i.imgur.com/Jy0nM91.png


My account email is [email protected]
My account id is Gxxxxxxx
My nickname is Albie

Any explanation why these weren't accepted? I feel they're up to standard, though that may just be me.  

Wait how do you guys know what got accepted? Can't open gifts yet...  

Posted by slyde

Wait how do you guys know what got accepted? Can't open gifts yet...

I assume they got their stuff/gralats added to them already (assuming they were accepted)  

Posted by slyde

Wait how do you guys know what got accepted? Can't open gifts yet...

Some of us submitted hats and they were added to our inventories the other day.  

It doesn't have to be something copyrighted. If it even looks like it was based on something copyright it won't be accepted to avoid the risk

Posted by slyde

Wait how do you guys know what got accepted? Can't open gifts yet...

The creators were messaged if their stuff was accepted  

Posted by Albie

None of my hats were added to my account. Does this mean they weren't accepted?
A lot of my hats were 10x better than some of the **** that got accepted this year

I agree with you, a lot of the has you made were pretty great!  

Posted by Ivy

I agree with you, a lot of the has you made were pretty great!

I wanna say the same for you but it's tempting....