When there's 3000+ hats on the server you're gonna have some that look similar  

Posted by ChocoNotes

When there's 3000+ hats on the server you're gonna have some that look similar

Posted by Rufus

2640 - Ash Ketchum
2743 - THE ACTUAL AMOUNT
2890 - Eldon

3k in early 2013.
more like 10k+ hats rn.  

Posted by Zetectic

3k in early 2013.
more like 10k+ hats rn.

Actual sold/available hats is probably nearer 3000
Still bloody loads for a game that insits it isn't a hat factory though  

Posted by OG

2nd hat looks like crap js, 1st hat is a classic hat that we all know and love and the 3rd hat is honestly amazing

If I had to choose between second and first hat, I'd choose the second one. I'm pretty sure nearly any professional pixel artist would tell you that the second hat is much better in comparison. Just because the 1st hat is a "classic hat" that we all "know and love" doesn't mean it's better.  

Only the 2 first are similar but Classic has hundreds/thousands of hats.