Some staff think of the rules differently. Sure, we have basic guidelines, but some staff are more extreme than others when it comes to following those guidelines. Try uploading it again at a later time. Maybe a different staff member will approve it.  

Thanks, Brick, for your responses.

As I've said, it's an ongoing issue that anyone with out-of-the-way ideas about graphics uploads might face. I don't want to break the rules, but I do want to find innovative ways of bending them in the process of being creative.  

"Too big" sometimes means it covers too much of the player's body.

Also I think they are no longer accepting certain template sizes... the umbrella I use a lot was deleted off the server, and was rejected when I tried re-uploading same image:/  

It didn't cover the body. I tried to make sure it was specifically outside the region of the player. My intention was to use statues to display the window-shield, and then cover them with pillars or strange bricks to make a sort of panel window effect...

And whatever happened to Bam's Flashy Scarf?