Bioshock Infinite would have had me with some sort of mode or multiplayer experience to play after the story. I haven't played a lot of games I wanted to try, like Disney Infinity, ACBF, Naruto Shippuden: Ultimate Ninja Storm 3, Tales of Xillia, etc. I guess my vote goes to Kingdom Hearts 1.5 HD ReMiX. It was my first time playing it and I'm glad I waited all those years, because it was worth it.