Christmas submission rage - 11

Ivy · 12-25-2015

Posted by Thallen

If that went into the actual rejection thought process, they could have at least made a submission cap and then people wouldn't be upset.
I don't see why there wasn't a 3-5 recolor limit either, seems reasonable. Now the guy who sent in 3 recolors of his hat is going to be buttsore because another guy had 8 recolors of his hat accepted, "Wahhh, I could have had more." Just seems like it was easily avoidable if outlined a little better.

I feel like Leah could privately tell people like Teacup why her hats were denied though? I mean, she took the time to make and submit them. The least the GATA could do is reply back with feedback or an explanation, takes 3 minutes. I get you can't do that for everyone, but at least for those who seem to have submitted quality work or a high number of pieces.

you're 100% right, but I have to spread rep.

ariana · 12-25-2015

Posted by Thallen

If that went into the actual rejection thought process, they could have at least made a submission cap and then people wouldn't be upset.
I don't see why there wasn't a 3-5 recolor limit either, seems reasonable. Now the guy who sent in 3 recolors of his hat is going to be buttsore because another guy had 8 recolors of his hat accepted, "Wahhh, I could have had more." Just seems like it was easily avoidable if outlined a little better.

I feel like Leah could privately tell people like Teacup why her hats were denied though? I mean, she took the time to make and submit them. The least the GATA could do is reply back with feedback or an explanation, takes 3 minutes. I get you can't do that for everyone, but at least for those who seem to have submitted quality work or a high number of pieces.

thats true.. some people do need an explinatioj because a few amazing gfx artists i know got their hats rejected and it doesnt make sense to me

TeacupDolly~ · 12-25-2015

what i'm thinking is maybe there were too many hats that were submitted into one category, coughcutecough, so that's why many weren't accepted, regardless of the quality?

Aguzo · 12-25-2015

Why does a staff need to give you an explanation about why your submissions weren't accepted?

Then they'd have to do that with everyone that is at least half decent at making hats?

There should not be a submission cap, because then people wouldn't submit a ton of content, and have even less odds to get their stuff chosen. "You can only get 3-4 recolors"... "Oh, I'll only make 3-4 then." It's better to just let them make as much as they can, so staff can have more options to choose from.

ChocoNotes · 12-25-2015

Posted by TeacupDolly~

what i'm thinking is maybe there were too many hats that were submitted into one category, coughcutecough, so that's why many weren't accepted, regardless of the quality?

That's what I was thinking, but surely there isn't a need for a limit, and if this was the case why not get rid of some recolours to allow more original hats?

Also;

VIP can now open gifts!
Non VIP can open in 2 hours

Got a ton of food and Ivys beanie so far

Ivy · 12-25-2015

Can't log in now lol

I'm on but its soooooo laggy lol

Livid · 12-25-2015

Posted by Ivy

Can't log in now lol

I'm on but its soooooo laggy lol

Same, its crazy.

Red · 12-25-2015

I want that mask marc has on, god dam.

Ivy · 12-25-2015

Posted by Livid

Same, its crazy.

Logged off because I couldn't do anything

Leah · 12-25-2015

Hi. I'd like to apologise for the inconvenience caused by our error. You have now been given the other hats which were approved, since it's only fair as others have received their full collections. Issues surrounding the recolours or minor edits of hats as multiple submissions will be discussed by staff involved to avoid any inconsistencies in the future.

Teacup Dolly's submissions are unrelated to this matter, but have now also been addressed. All gifts are finalised as they can now be opened, so no changes or extra submissions can take place. If you have any questions regarding why your submission was not accepted then feel free to send me a PM. Merry Christmas!

Red · 12-25-2015

Posted by Aguzo

Why does a staff need to give you an explanation about why your submissions weren't accepted?

Then they'd have to do that with everyone that is at least half decent at making hats?

Because that is what criticism is? How the **** is it fair for someone to spend hours on end making different hats and then trying to tweak, re-shade, shade some more then re color or redesign them AND not receive any reason as to why their submission was accepted.

When it comes to hypocrites you're right up there buddy, You love to complain about **** that does not go your way as well.

Ivy · 12-25-2015

Posted by Leah

Hi. I'd like to apologise for the inconvenience caused by our error. You have now been given the other hats which were approved, since it's only fair as others have received their full collections. Issues surrounding the recolours or minor edits of hats as multiple submissions will be discussed by staff involved to avoid any inconsistencies in the future.

Teacup Dolly's submissions are unrelated to this matter, but have now also been addressed. All gifts are finalised as they can now be opened, so no changes or extra submissions can take place. If you have any questions regarding why your submission was not accepted then feel free to send me a PM. Merry Christmas!

You blocked me on game.

Incognito · 12-25-2015

Posted by Aguzo

Why does a staff need to give you an explanation about why your submissions weren't accepted?

Then they'd have to do that with everyone that is at least half decent at making hats?

Some of these submissions gathered positive feedback from people, even graphics admins, so I think an explanation is the least they can do if they're going to reject it.
And for a beginner like myself it would be great to gather feedback from a primary source so I can improve next year

also i cant even log on graal and im vip so i could be opening my gifts rn

Ivy · 12-25-2015

Posted by Incognito

Some of these submissions gathered positive feedback from people, even graphics admins, so I think an explanation is the least they can do if they're going to reject it.
And for a beginner like myself it would be great to gather feedback from a primary source so I can improve next year

also i cant even log on graal and im vip so i could be opening my gifts rn

Same

Livid · 12-25-2015

Posted by OG

Because that is what criticism is? How the **** is it fair for someone to spend hours on end making different hats and then trying to tweak, re-shade, shade some more then re color or redesign them AND not receive any reason as to why their submission was accepted.

When it comes to hypocrites you're right up there buddy, You love to complain about **** that does not go your way as well.

Now that was an unwanted, rude, and jerky response rather than a civilized one.

12-25-2015	153
TeacupDolly~ a ghost Join Date: Dec 2013 Location: somewhere over the rainbow Posts: 140	what i'm thinking is maybe there were too many hats that were submitted into one category, coughcutecough, so that's why many weren't accepted, regardless of the quality?

12-25-2015	154
Aguzo Registered User Join Date: May 2013 Posts: 3,027	Why does a staff need to give you an explanation about why your submissions weren't accepted? Then they'd have to do that with everyone that is at least half decent at making hats? There should not be a submission cap, because then people wouldn't submit a ton of content, and have even less odds to get their stuff chosen. "You can only get 3-4 recolors"... "Oh, I'll only make 3-4 then." It's better to just let them make as much as they can, so staff can have more options to choose from.

12-25-2015	156
Ivy Earning Unix dem stacks Join Date: Apr 2013 Location: In a fox hole somewhere Posts: 7,391	Can't log in now lol I'm on but its soooooo laggy lol

12-25-2015	158
Red Banned Join Date: Sep 2014 Location: Australia Posts: 3,255	I want that mask marc has on, god dam.

12-25-2015	160
Leah Cow Lover Join Date: Apr 2013 Location: Northern Ireland Posts: 39	Hi. I'd like to apologise for the inconvenience caused by our error. You have now been given the other hats which were approved, since it's only fair as others have received their full collections. Issues surrounding the recolours or minor edits of hats as multiple submissions will be discussed by staff involved to avoid any inconsistencies in the future. Teacup Dolly's submissions are unrelated to this matter, but have now also been addressed. All gifts are finalised as they can now be opened, so no changes or extra submissions can take place. If you have any questions regarding why your submission was not accepted then feel free to send me a PM. Merry Christmas!